RV Ratings Independent Nonprofit
Rating RVs for over 20 years
| |
|
|
How We Rate RVs
Highway Control is generated with data received from the RV's manufacturer,
often supplemented by information furnished by consumer
users. Because most handling characteristics have been
proven to be a result of good or bad engineering and
assembly, it is relatively easy to show that driver
control can be easily lost when the RV is overloaded,
out of balance or, in the case of motor homes, designed
with an inadequate wheelbase for the vehicle's length.
Getting a good Highway Control Rating is both delicate
and complicated. Although we use other factors in addition
to those discussed here, weights and wheelbase are of
extreme importance.
The Highway Control Rating is based on a 1-to-100 scale that gives a representation of the ability of the trailer to be controlled by the driver — especially under adverse road and weather conditions. Specifically, this is the rating of the RV's ability to respond to your commands and be reasonably safe. Payload capacity, hitch weight percentages, and size are the primary factors for travel trailers.
Manufacturers often change the specifications after initial production of new models and brochures. This, of course, upsets the apple cart. If we get this new information, we enter it as a midyear change, indicated by “myc” in the model field. If we do not get the change but the dealer does, you might think that our information is inaccurate and accept the dealer's data as accurate. The danger here is that the manufacturer has produced later models with earlier specifications — which in some cases are models you might not want. It never hurts to check the ID tags on the vehicle for correct specifications.
RVCG has full confidence in the ability of the formulas
to arrive at the final number, but we acknowledge that
the manufacturer must provide accurate information for
this system to work. After many years of working with
manufacturers, we know that most manufacturers provide
reasonably accurate data. However, there are those few
who appear to have little inclination to give the consumer
complete data even though it is the standard in the
industry to do so. In our rating system we inform the
consumer when it appears that a manufacturer provides
incomplete or questionable data.
Highway Control: Wheelbase for Motorhomes
Because it is
easier for motor home manufacturers to build and sell
short-wheelbase motor homes, this is an area of controversy
for the RVCG ratings. Manufacturers know that overloading
and being out of balance are both dangerous situations
which are easily reflected by chassis capacities, total
weights, and at-wheel weights. They are aware that their
customers will know if the motor home is severely out-of-balance.
There is no argument here. What they won't acknowledge
is something the rest of the world knows a short-wheelbase
vehicle is difficult to control when driving on slippery,
gravelly, or wet roads and that they have a propensity
to wander. RVCG uses long-established empirical data
to reflect wheelbase into the Highway Control Rating.
There is no guesswork here.
Highway Control: Hitch Weights for Towables
One thing that is absolutely
clear about highway control when towing a fifth wheel
or trailer coach is that proper hitch weight is critical
to the prevention of an accident. RVCG looks at the
optimum hitch weights that have been established by
the RV industry for over 30 years and uses that data
to determine extremes. It has been proven beyond a shadow
of a doubt that too light of a hitch weight has caused
more accidents than all other deficiencies combined
and that too heavy of a hitch weight is the second most
common cause of trailer-related accidents. RVCG uses
the manufacturer's own numbers backed up by consumer
input to arrive at this part of the Highway Control
Rating.

Back to Ratings Terms
|
| |
|